Relijournal > Religion

Theology: Mohammed Vs. Jesus Christ

A comparative analysis of Islam's greatest prophet and the Son of God. WARNING: This is a theological argument so if you are offended, please do not read on. Some parts of the argument may be against your beliefs but that is what makes theological arguments fun!

Page 1 of 4 | Prev 1234Next»

From the dusty plains of Mesopotamia, the father of all believers - Abraham - brought onto the world the early practices of monotheistic religions. His first illegitimate son, Ishmael, was blessed by God and became the father of the original Arab population, and through his lineage, became the father of Islam. Abraham's first born Isaac, was blessed through the covenant and became the father of the Hebrew peoples and Judaism was born through his lineage. As the centuries passed, the promise of a Messiah to bring about salvation and an ever-lasting kingdom of God through the line of David was fulfilled when Jesus Christ was born in David's royal family (through Joseph).

Upon crucifixion of Jesus, much of the prophesies were completed and the reformed Judaism, known first in Antioch as the “Christians” or followers of Christ, was born. Although Judaism and Christianity share a close tie, Christianity is seen as a continuation or what is the “post-messiah” era, where the promise of God's salvation for mankind is being fulfilled. Islam came about 600 years after Christianity was born, and borrowed heavily from Judaism, Christianity and Zoroastrianism. Today, Christianity and Islam has the largest followers in the world and is among the fastest growing religions in the world, yet both religions have developed fundamental differences in their theological statements, treatment of individuals and their interactions with each other.

Much of what Christianity and Islam shares are considered heretical by both sides, but there are truths that must be considered. For example, in Islam, the Qur'an states that Isaac and his progeny are blessed as long as they uphold their covenant with God. Christians believed that God gave a covenant to Abraham and through the covenant; Abraham and his sons are blessed - the present day Jewish/Israeli population. Even though Qur'an does not specifically say Israel or Jews, Isaac's children are the Jewish and Israeli population. And Judaism shares the same belief that they are a blessed people from God. Yet, as cultural and political differences began to grow after the death of Mohammad, beliefs changed. Some early Muslims believed that Isaac was the son who was supposed to be sacrificed by Abraham. However, after a few centuries, this view was not supported by Islamic Scholars.

Just like the view of Islam and Isaac, Islam has the same view of Jesus Christ. Early Muslims, even Mohammad the prophet, viewed and respected Jesus Christ as one of the holiest, if not the holiest, of God's prophets send to mankind to bring people back to God. On the flip side, Christians, from the very beginning, have viewed Jesus Christ as the “son of God,” who was born to a virgin in the family of King David, to save mankind from their destruction and establish closer ties to God. However, as time went on, Islamic scholars and the Caliphate dynasties moved away from Jesus as the holiest prophet to Mohammad being the holiest prophet and Jesus following Mohammad's footsteps… when in reality Jesus did his ministry 600 years before Mohammad was even born. Christians also believe that Jesus Christ was crucified for our sins, to bring salvation onto mankind and then raised from the dead. This view was first used by early Muslims in the Arabian Peninsula but that also soon changed as Muslims began to view Jesus as a prophet who was sentenced to be crucified, but someone else died for him while Jesus was miraculously saved. Thus, Muslims deny Jesus was dead and then rose from the dead, but Muslims do accept that Jesus did spend a little time with his disciples and then was taken up into heaven. This interpretation may be a simple theological misinterpretation by the Islamic scholars, because in the Qur'an, Surat Maryam (Mary) 19:33, it says “Peace me on that day I was born, and the day I die, and the day I shall be raised alive,” a statement made by Jesus during his life when he was taking about his death. It clearly means that Jesus died through crucifixion and then rose from the dead, a fact that Qur'an acknowledges as well as some of the early Muslims but denied by the current religious authorities. This is further reinforced in Surat al-Baqarah (Cow) 2:87, where it clearly says that the son of Mary, Jesus, was slain. There is no way to misinterpret “slain” for another definition, meaning slain means Jesus was killed. How was he killed? The Gospels is the only authentic source that provides that answer through many of its scriptural passages, that Jesus was crucified.

Yet the problem arises in the fact that many modern Muslims believe that the Christian and Jewish texts are not the same as they were before. This means that none of the present-day teachings of Christianity and Judaism are valid in the eyes of Muslims worldwide, but Christians and Jews are still considered the “people of the book” since they were the first ones to receive the word of God. Muslims believe that Moses got the books of the Law (Taurat or the Pentateuch books) while David for the songs (Zabur or Psalms) and Jesus was given the Evangels (Injil or the Gospels). This is seen throughout Suras such as 17:55, 19:30, 40:53 and many others. Now modern day Muslims believe that after Mohammed declared that the Koran was made to verify the Christian and Jewish texts (Bibles), they were altered to include Jesus Christ as the savior son of God. In the bible, Jesus says “I am the way and the truth and the life.

Page 1 of 4 | Prev 1234Next»
24
Liked It
I Like It!
Related Articles
Christianity, Islam, and Hinduism: Comparing and Contrasting  |  Cafeteria Christianity
Comments (24)
#1 by Jawed Iqbal, May 18, 2008
A theological comparative analysis...?? sounds more like a biased diatribe of a prejudiced person. Most of what you have written regarding Islam is simply false. You need to get your sources correct. Read my latest article so you would know where to get authentic information about Islam next time.
#2 by stephanus, May 20, 2008
I have nothing against Islam as I am a strong advocate for interreligious dialogue and friendship. However, you mentioned one thing which I also find somewhat unclear in Islam. The Qu'ran mentions about the "Hawris", virgin-wives-to-be of a good muslim in paradise, but it does not mention "virgin-husbands-to-be" for good muslim women. Isn't that unfair for women? Besides,Jesus mentioned in the Bible that in the after life, we will not marry anymore because we will be like angels. How could muslims accept Jesus as a prophet when his very words are being contradicted by the teachings of Muhammed? Salam!!
#3 by James, May 22, 2008
I have to agree with stephanus here on this one, how can Muslims accept Jesus as their prophet when his teachings are contradictory to the teachings of Muhammad and the Koran? The article also mentions the fact that the afterlife in Islam is all about women and wine but what about the Islamic women? Do they get the men and wine in their afterlife or do they wear a burqa and stay hidden somewhere?? In Christian afterlife, it is a fellowship with God, not wine and sex.
#4 by Jason, Jun 25, 2008
This is not a real debate between Mohammed and Jesus, but more a one sided argument biased heavily to one side. Title should really read, \"Why Jesus is better than Mohammed\".
#5 by Gita, Jul 17, 2008
I agree, Jesus Christ is the only leader that has died for love and for his message by a world that hated him and now his message of love is stronger than ever. God loves mankind and wants to build a stronger relationship with man. In Islam, God is a faraway being that is unapproachable by man - while man is thrown at the mercy of God who can change his mind at any time and operates with no principles.
#6 by Hamba Allah, Aug 6, 2008
Bismillaahirrahmaaniraahim. In the name of Allah I\'d like to explain that:
1. Islam is the only religion that truly has one God, Allah SWT;

2. You can not see Al Quran only half or one surah (letter of God), you must see whole of the Al Quran. You can not give summary (carelessly) that Isa AS was sussessfully murdered or being crossed you must know that Isa AS had been saved by Allah. You must know that that interpretation was stated when the Isa still live, he don\'t know what life will happen next when Allah SWT actually and really saved him.

3. Do not translate carelessly in another language you must understand in Arabic Language. That\'s why Islam do not carelessly translate AL Quran in any language.

4. About Islam and the rules of woman, I am muslimah, you must know that Islam very protect us in the rules to use Hijab, the clothes that protect us from top to toe, we are protected by Allah SWT (Almighty) from man or men\'s rape. About inheritances, we get inheritances in fairly number. Woman muslim (Muslimah can get knowledge and religion as same as man (muslim). We can freely express our opinion without any difficulties.

5. Haram (forbidden) in Islamic livelihood to drink wine(khamr) or alcoholic drink. See Al Quraan in Al Baqarah and Al Maidah! Ah, if you say that Christian drink wine, I believe so because I often see them in television.

6. How can you accept the truth about Islamic religion if you still not fair to see about one prophet and another and you are musyrik (ally Allah SWT with another else).

7. Do you use your mind and heart to feel and think who is the truly creator who had created this: earth,planets, and universe before the creature itself (human, animal, angel, and satan/devil, and jin, and so on))Can you reach your brain? Isa AS or Jesus that you said, was born after another prophet and nabi? After Adam AS was created by Allah SWT. Can you reach your mind?

8. Impossible that Allah SWT has a child, Allah SWT(God) has no gender. Allah is Allah. Allah is not female and man. Allah different with Allah\'s creature because Allah is a God.

9. If you want to say that Christian is better than Muslim. Think again thousand times if you still can not reach your mind. Your conclusion is unuseful. Your understands in Al Quran are falsely.

10. Last but not least. Learn arabic! Understand Al Quran! Iqro! Don\'t spell Muhammad with ...o..Muhammad SAW is Muhammad SAW.
#7 by Hamba Allah, Aug 6, 2008
To Stephanus, did you ever hear that Injil or Bible that you hold has been get some touch by human with Old Agreement Version and New Agreement Version of Bible. How can you guarantee if your bible that you hold still pure without any mix or mingle of human? Al Quran, when Muhammad lived, we, muslim were always memorizing Al Quran. The pure and holy Al Quran still saved by Allah SWT. Al Quran is only one version since Muhammad lived. We never change the contain . We never give touch anything. If someone gives add or less to Al Quran in Arabic or meaning, he/or she will get punishment from Allah SWT and Muslim.
#8 by Hamba Allah, Aug 6, 2008
To: Stephanus you are asking: How could muslims accept Jesus as a prophet when his very words are being contradicted by the teachings of Muhammed? Salam!!

The word that Muhammad tell to us are not contradicted with Isa Alaihi Salam or you called him as Jesus. They are from same roots, Ibrahim (you called himm as Abraham), Muhammad is the successor of Ismail AS. Isa AS is successor of Maryam, successor of Ishaq (you called him as Isaac). They are teach us one believing since Adam AS was being created by Allah SWT that,"There is no god but Allah Almighty, do not ally Allah SWT with anything else."
To: James
I'm happy to be perfect virgin-wives-to-be of a good muslim in paradise. Of coure there (in paradise) will be perfect virgin-husbands-to-be of a good muslim in paradise. Do you want to be like that, James. Only if you do not ally with anything else.
To: Jason,
There is no prophet better than another, we can not judge it because only Allah SWT that has integrity to valued Allah's prayer. Muhammad SAW and Isa AS (you called him as Jesus) are brothers, how can you say "VS" there?
In fact, whatever Isa AS was, we respect him we do not become as a muslim if ... we do not respect him.
Jamalakallaah (Hope Allah SWT gives you a clue or Hidayah)
Don't judge Islam everybody if you still less in understanding of Islam. You can contact me all the time in this Blog, Triond.com in my own address. Hamba Allah.
#9 by Hamba Allah, Aug 6, 2008
Of course there (in paradise) will be perfect virgin-husbands-to-be of a good muslim in paradise.
#10 by Hamba Allah, Aug 6, 2008
To the author of this page, Ebey Soman,Hope Allah SWT give you a clue or hidayah. You have said:In the bible, Jesus says “I am the way and the truth and the life". Of course, here, we as a muslim that false because we always compare between Al Quran and Injil contains. The truth and the life here,we must understand as sa AS is someone that bring news of the truth from his The Only, Allah SWT that There is no god but Allah, do not ally Allah SWT with anything else, the life is Isa AS bring a lesson from his The Only God that a person or people can get joy and happiness if they are still hold this lesson,There is no god but Allah, do not ally Allah SWT with anything else. Jamalakallaah!
#11 by Hamba Allah, Aug 6, 2008
Hope Allah SWT gives you a clue or hidayah
#12 by Hamba muslim, Aug 6, 2008
Recover the statement above ,Astaghfirullah I mean: we as a muslim can not say that false because we always compare between Al Quran and Injil contains
#13 by Hamba Allah, Aug 6, 2008
To: Ebey Soman, there is useless to make Christian and Muslim debate. Do you think this is Playstation or what? There is no benefit to smear another religion like this. Keep searchin the truth, Guys! Do not hate to someone religion! Hope Allah SWT will lead us to The Real Heaven.
#14 by Hamba Allah, Aug 6, 2008
The truth and the life here,we must understand as Isa AS is someone that bring joyful news of the truth from his The Only, Allah SWT that There is no god but Allah, do not ally Allah SWT with anything else, the life is Isa AS bring a lesson from his The Only God that a person or people can get joy and happiness if they are still hold this lesson,There is no god but Allah, do not ally Allah SWT with anything else. Jamalakallaah!
#15 by Karen, Aug 28, 2008
Jesus Crist is my Lord and Savior. I don\'t understand a whole bunch about Muslim religion. I do know that is was formed out of the adulterous act of Abraham and the maidservents child correct? My instinct with Muslims is that they become so hateful and evil when Allah is slandered. Why in the world would Allah want his people to kill other people?
#16 by ngse, Oct 2, 2008
tell you what, mohamed was an evil snake who got his inspirations from a so called angel
in a cave
wow thats strange.
To follow someone as mohamed means certain death in hellfire
mohamed has died who can dispute this. did jesus die?
no he lives!!
#17 by ally, Oct 10, 2008
if i were the author,i'd really do the theological analysis and not biased analysis.i didn't know "theological analysis" means abusing someone else.may Allah show you the right path.
#18 by ally, Oct 10, 2008
tell me, what did Issa AS mean when he said "i only give tell what God has sent me for because i am only a messenger of God".
#19 by Mike, Oct 10, 2008
To Ally when you say Issa it means you are talking about Jesus. But i read the bible and i can tell you that Jesus never said that.
#20 by Blue, Oct 11, 2008
If Allah will really bring all of us to the \"real heaven\" or will he only bring the ones who believe him? In Christianity Jesus Christ suffered and died for our sins to be able for ALL who believe in Him will be accepted in heaven. But if you ABSOLUTELY don\'t have faith in Him then you will be brought to the fires of hell and suffer eternal pain.

And I agree to Karen, why do Muslims need to kill other peaople. Do you need to do it to be able to bring your self to \"your heaven\", Thats selfishness. If you kill them do you not think about them if they will still be brought to heaven?

Hail the King Jesus Christ our Savior!!! Alleluia!!!
#21 by Blue, Oct 11, 2008
And also, whp do you think are good people?

Muslims
-who are united to do bad things to those who contradict their religion.
-who are permitted to have many mives and to have sex.

or

Christians
-who just fight a litle then forgive the people who contradict our religion.
-who are only permitted to have only one wife and have self controll with sex.



And also, if people think Christianity is against Sciene.. Then think again.. In the creation,

God said: \"Let there be light\", and there was light.
In science in coordination with the big bang thory: When the big ball of mass exploded, what do you think happend, it produced light as a normal explotion would do.

then so on..
if in God, He only created the universe and the world in only 6 days.. in science it happend billions of years.. but think again.. it happened in the same order..
#22 by Phantom, Oct 14, 2008
What is happening on this page is the exact reason why we as children do not have a relationship with G-D anymore. We run off with a piece of the puzzle that we do not fully understand and bring more confusion upon ourselves. The answer is not entirely in one religion or the other. Why are there so many religions? Why do many of them share things in common with other religions yet claim the other to be false and blasphemous? We must realize that there are thousands of religions that over centuries have changed regardless of how it is believed to be uncorrupted. Nothing is incorruptible. Only those who understand what truly happened at Babel and know to seek for wisdom and understanding dilligently without prejudice can know and have a true relationship with the true G-D. People please open your eyes and see to know that the enemy has us exactly where he wants us and thats against each other. Division will never bring the solution Most, regardless of how strong they believe in whatever religion will remain lost till the end.
#23 by voks, Nov 3, 2008
phantom is right. religion will remain lost till the end but God is God. i can not worship a tree and assume that it\'s my creator. secondly the mode by which you pray to your God matters. the truth be God wants us to love each other and God is the supreme judge, God is the giver and taker of life, God made every thing, God wants us to live in harmony and fulfill our purpose in this world and every human being is equal. if the religion you are following does not preach this you are on the wrong path. and it was religious people who killed my lord and master Jesus Christ.
#24 by  Squish, Dec 10, 2008
Wow! Some of the comments I've just ready are absolutely retarded. You people need to read more!


To the people near the top...

Jesus is accepted by Muslims as a prophet because he was one. His teachings aren't seen by SCHOLARLY Muslims as "contradictory". Instead, Muslims believe that the Gospels in the NT are not the teachings of Jesus. Instead, they feel that Jesus produced a long lost Gospel that had what Jesus truly taught in it. Since then, they feel that the message has been tampered with. they use this as one of the reasons why Islam had to be. It was needed to correct the changes to the Christian message.

Hambah Allah, you were by far the voice of reason in these comments. Nevertheless, you said "Islam is the only religion that truly has one God, Allah SWT". I find this to be quite an unsupportable statement. I mean, I'll give you that Christianity has the trinity which keeps it from being truly monotheist (at least in Muslim eyes). However, what category would Judaism fall into under your statement. The Jews have had one God for far longer than the Muslims and it is the same God. As far as I know they at least would have to be deemed monotheist. In addition, a further study of World Religions (especially Asian) will turn up far more truly monotheist religions. Nearly every Eastern religion has at least one monotheist sect. Hinduism, which is normally understood as polytheism, in fact has several monotheist sects within. All forms of animism also usually focus on a single "earth mother" which is monotheist.

And to now to correct a few of the thoughts I've heard throughout the comments. First off, Muslims do not support terrorism or suicide bombings. It is very against their religion and denounced by all. The people engaging in such acts are extremists that are outcasts from the religion. Saying that all Muslims support terror is like saying that the Catholic church supports Nazis (which it it did during Hitler's reign in Germany). You guys need to get your facts straight. Read a book on Islam before you start making accusations. I don't blame you though, the media have always slaughtered the Muslims who were one of the most important peoples of time. Next time, just find out for yourselves rather than trusting others words.

Not that that's cleared up, I'll move onto the article. Rather than pointing out its in errancies, I'll just hit the broad overview. First off, it's a theological interpretation as stated in the title. It does not compare the two religions, simply their spiritual leaders THEOLOGICAL teachings. One must keep in mind that this is only the religious sphere covered. If in fact the political realm is taken into consideration, Muhammad wins hands down. Jesus only taught in the religious sphere whereas Muhammad led in both the religious and political spheres. His teachings (or at least the examples of him found in the Hadith) were far more practical and much less shrouded in spirituality than Jesus' teachings. Starting a religion and starting a new form of government are two completely different tasks. Nevertheless, this article does focus on theology. In that respect, a comparison still cannot truly be drawn. We must keep in mind that Jesus formed his teachings without worrying about politics. He had a huge advantage in this respect. He had to teach absolutely nothing about politics. Muhammad on the other hand had to intertwine the secular and the religious to maintain a perfect balance. In this respect at least, Muhammad was twice the leader Jesus was.

Well there is my $0.02

Squish
Post Your Comment:
Name:  
Copy the code into this box:  
Post comment with your Triond credentials?
Inside Relijournal

Buddhism

 /

Christianity

 /

Hinduism

 /

Islam

 /

Judaism

 /

Paganism

 /

Religion


Popular Tags
Popular Writers
Powered by
Relijournal
About Us
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
Services
Submit an Article
Advertise with Us
Contact

© 2007 Copyright Stanza Ltd. All Rights Reserved.